2020 GRT college football picks: Bowls

After two weeks of right around 60% on all games, the GRT Statsy Preview Machine took a pie in the face this week, going only 7-12 (36.84%) overall, 1-5 (16.67%) in Category 2, and 0-4 ( let me see . . . 0%) in Category 3. For the season, the Machine is now 267-235 (53.19%) in Category 1, 100-83 (54.64%) in Category 2, and 54-43 (55.67%) in Category 3.

Because the Machine struck out on Category 3 games, it also struck out on both “Category 4” games. For the seven weeks we’ve been tracking Cat 4 games, they are 19-5 (79.16%).

The Machine had an identical result for all games using mid-week spreads: 7-12 (36.84%).

SP+, meanwhile, had a solid week, going 11-8 (58%) officially, using its own mid-week spreads. For the season, SP+ is 258-243-7 (52%). It had the same results against opening spreads (11-8, 57.89%) and is now 280-222 (55.78%) for the season against those spreads.

Below are the GRT Statsy Preview Machine’s picks for the 2020 college football bowl season. As always, if you’re wondering why we do this or what I mean when I refer to “confidence” and when I place game predictions into different categories, check out this post. Also, in case it’s not perfectly clear from the above results, spreads matter.

GRT SPM 2020 Bowl Picks

Ignore the Home and Away column headings again this week, as bowls are all neutral site games. I’ve accounted for them in the calculations, but haven’t denoted them in the table.

Bowl season features seven Category 3 games, those that the GRT Statsy Preview Machine likes particularly well. Of those, the following five make the Category 4 cut because they also agree with SP+:

  • Iowa vs. Missouri (Iowa -13.5)
  • Tulsa vs. Mississippi State (Tulsa -1.5)
  • Marshall vs. Buffalo (Marshall +3.5)
  • North Carolina State vs. Kentucky (North Carolina State +2.5)
  • Texas A&M vs. North Carolina (North Carolina +5.5)

I’m really interested to see how the Statsy Preview Machine does in this weird season where there were very few, if any, data points for cross-conference play. I’m hoping that its focus on how a team does relative to what its opponents usually do does a good job of predicting how it will do against any opponent regardless of conference affiliation or schedule strength. We’ll see.

Tennessee-St. Joseph’s Four Factors Gameplan: Dealer’s Choice

Here’s the GRT Four Factors Gameplan for Tennessee’s game against the St. Joseph’s Hawks tonight.

Summary and Score Prediction

You have to hand it to Saint Joseph’s: Three of their first five games (including tonight against the Vols) will be against Top 10 teams. Keep that in mind when you cast a dismissive glance at their stats to date. On the other hand, the Vols aren’t likely to make things any easier for the Hawks tonight, and their stats will likely hold until their schedule lets up. Which shouldn’t be tonight.

Tennessee should have a chance to further improve its shooting percentages this evening and should be able to continue its dominance on the defensive end, forcing turnovers and tough shots without fouling and rebounding many of the misses. Bottom line: Tennessee appears to have the advantage in every facet of the game tonight.

So here’s our humble suggestion on how to better enjoy the game tonight by knowing what to watch for:

  1. Expect Tennessee to have sort of a dealer’s choice, either choosing their flavor of success or just playing until the smoothest of paths becomes evident.
  2. If they choose to work on things they’re not yet doing especially well, watch for the offense to continue to solve the “good shots” puzzle, increasing their percentages both from the field and from the three-point line, and also improving their ability to draw fouls and earn three throw attempts.

Vegas has Tennessee as a 20.5-point favorite. KenPom likes the Vols by 19 and puts the score at Tennessee 83, Saint Joseph’s 64, which translates into a 96% chance of winning.

According to our fledgling Hoops Statsy Preview Machine, Tennessee is scoring 116% of what its opponents usually give up and allowing only 68% of what those opponents usually get. Those numbers for Saint Joseph’s are 115% and 117%. It thinks the Vols cover pretty easily tonight. It’s also been wrong a lot, as it’s still finding its wings.

Details below.


Baseline

Here’s what each team looks like at this point of the season.

Hmm. That’s looking pretty good so far.

Four Factors: Straight-Up

Effective FG%

Conclusion: Not terrible shooters at this point. Most like Cincinnati.

Turnover %

Conclusion: I know I’m supposed to be looking at St. Joe’s, but I’m getting distracted by that No. 15 ranking for Tennessee. In turnover percentage! Woo. Huge improvement from last season so far.

Oh, and I almost forgot: The Hawks aren’t bad in this category.

Offensive Rebound %

Conclusion: More green for the Vols. Loving that. Also digging that Saint Joseph’s is really pretty bad at offensive rebounding.

Free Throw Rate

Conclusion: Well. The green party is over, apparently. Good news, though. The Hawks aren’t getting to the free throw line any more often than the Vols.

Four Factors: Opponent impact

Effective FG%

Conclusions

So the Vols have been shooting better recently but still have a ways to go. It appears that they’ll have an opportunity to improve that again tonight, although Will wisely points out that the Hawks have played a pretty wicked schedule so far this young season.

On the other side of the court, Tennessee’s defense continues to throttle the enthusiasm out of opponents and will likely continue to do so tonight against the Hawks.

Turnover %

Conclusions

Woo. We’re not giving the ball up, and we’re taking it away from opponents. Big advantages for the good guys in turnovers tonight.

Offensive Rebounding %

Conclusions

Ooh! Not only are the Vols super good at offensive rebounding and really good on the defensive boards as well, but Saint Joseph’s is apparently all too willing to just concede rebounds on both sides of the court. Nice.

Free Throw Rate

Conclusions

Well, who needs free throws anyway? The Hawks aren’t likely to even get a whiff of the free throw stripe tonight due to them not knowing the way and Tennessee crushing the compass. The Vols aren’t much better about getting there, although it looks like St. Joseph’s might make things easier in that regard this evening.

Go Vols.

While we wait, basketball!

Whatever is or isn’t going to happen with Jeremy Pruitt, the surest joy one can choose in the athletic department right now is back on the floor tonight at 6:00 PM against Saint Joseph’s (SEC Network). The Hawks are 0-4 but have faced the sixth-toughest schedule in the nation, losing to Auburn by five in overtime, Kansas by 18, Drexel by four, and Villanova by 20. They won’t be particularly intimidated by Tennessee on the front end, though the Volunteer defense has a way of doing that by itself once these games get going.

Tennessee’s offense is coming along nicely too, bolstered by a 103-point performance against Tennessee Tech last week. Jaden Springer became the first Vol to hit 20+ points in that contest, and is now averaging an efficient 12.5 points in 19.5 minutes per game. The really interesting thing with this group is how it feels like seven different players could lead the team in scoring on a given night.

In the early going John Fulkerson (12.8), Springer (12.5), Victor Bailey (10.8), and Josiah James (10.5) all average double figures. Keon Johnson is at 7.5 in 18.3 minutes. And we know Yves Pons (6.8) and Santiago Vescovi (5.8) are capable of an outburst as well.

The freshmen will continue to get plenty of opportunities, and Tennessee may continue to run a lot of its desired offense through Fulkerson, who still leads the team in field goal attempts despite foul trouble in the opener. But we’re also seeing early signs of the efficiency that can come from great ball movement to so many options. Not only is Jaden Springer proving to be a reliable threat (19-of-29 from the floor, 4-of-5 from three), but Josiah James isn’t far behind him (13-of-28 from the floor, 6-of-11 from three, 10-of-10 from the line).

Saint Joseph’s has a decent offense, comparable to what we saw from Cincinnati though they go about it with far less height. But their defense has struggled to keep up with better talent, 249th nationally in defensive efficiency. And 48 hours later the Vols will host USC Upstate, a team on par with the Tennessee Tech squad that just lost by 54 points.

But after that it’s a week off, then SEC play on December 30 at #16 Missouri. Two more chances to tune it up. But with nothing certain on the football side of things right now, Rick Barnes’ basketball squad is truly a gift to be enjoyed this time of year, and perhaps deep into March.

GRT Bowl Pick ‘Em

Well, a weird year gets weirder: the College Football Playoff field was announced yesterday, which means bowls start (checks calendar)…today. So jump in our free bowl pick ’em with confidence points at Fun Office Pools.

Today’s first game is at 2:30 PM ET, but as always we’ve made the earliest kick worth the fewest confidence points. So if you’re coming to this late, you’ll only be one point behind.

Good luck!

It’s a tight race after Week 16 of the GRT Guessing Game

Here’s the play-by-play for this week’s Guessing Game.

Week 16 – Texas A&M

Round 1

Q: What does the Vols’ offense do most often on first down? (30 – 60 points available)

A: Throw the ball (60 points) (by my count, this was 10 passes to 8 runs on first down, assuming the sacks were pass plays)

These players got this right:

  • Joel Hollingsworth
  • Josh Farrar
  • Will Shelton
  • Harley

Mushrooms (30 points): Joel Hollingsworth and Harley

Bananas (-30 points): Josh Farrar and Will Shelton

Blue shells and bolts: 

  • Blue Shell No. 10 (launched by Jayyyy): Counter 3
  • Blue Shell No. 11 (launched by Raven17): Counter 4
  • New Blue Shell No. 12 (launched by Sam Hensley): Counter 5
  • No bolts

Top 10 after Round 1:

  1. Joel Hollingsworth (1540)
  2. Isaac Bishop (1470)
  3. Josh Farrar (1390)
  4. LTVol99 (1292)
  5. Jayyyy (1237)
  6. HixsonVol (1162)
  7. Mitchell K (1147)
  8. raven17 (1128)
  9. Harley (502)
  10. Will Shelton (472)

Round 2

Q: How many passing yards does Kellen Mond get? (50 – 70 points available)

A: 251 – 300 yards (60 points) (he had 281)

These players got this right and got 50 points for it:

  • Jayyyy
  • Will Shelton
  • JWheel101

Mushrooms (30 points): Harley and Will Shelton

Bananas (-30 points): Isaac Bishop and Jayyyy

Blue shells and bolts: 

  • Blue Shell No. 10 (launched by Jayyyy): Counter 2
  • Blue Shell No. 11 (launched by Raven17): Counter 3
  • Blue Shell No. 12 (launched by Sam Hensley): Counter 4
  • No new blue shells or bolts

Top 10 after Round 2:

  1. Joel Hollingsworth (1540)
  2. Isaac Bishop (1440)
  3. Josh Farrar (1390)
  4. LTVol99 (1292)
  5. Jayyyy (1267)
  6. HixsonVol (1162)
  7. Mitchell K (1147)
  8. raven17 (1128)
  9. Will Shelton (562)
  10. Harley (532)

Round 3

Choose Your Booster. Here were the options, along with the results:

Vols’ points times 10130
Vols’ net passing yards times 1189
Vols’ net rushing yards times 1.331.2

These folks got the 189:

  • Joel Hollingsworth
  • Isaac Bishop
  • Jayyyy
  • raven17
  • Sam Hensley

These folks got the 130:

  • Josh Farrar
  • Will Shelton
  • Harley
  • JWheel101

Mushrooms (30 points): Isaac Bishop got both of the mushrooms

Bananas (-30 points): Josh Farrar and Sam Hensley

Blue shells and bolts: 

  • Blue Shell No. 10 (launched by Jayyyy): Counter 1
  • Blue Shell No. 11 (launched by Raven17): Counter 2
  • Blue Shell No. 12 (launched by Sam Hensley): Counter 3
  • No new blue shells or bolts

Rain Checks

These people get the rain check:

  • Will Shelton
  • JWheel101
  • Harley
  • Sam Hensley

They all chose the points x 10 and got 130 points.

Final Standings After Week 16:

Rank Player Points
1 Joel Hollingsworth 1729
2 Isaac Bishop 1689
3 Josh Farrar 1650
4 Jayyyy 1645
5 raven17 1506
6 LTVol99 1292
7 HixsonVol 1162
8 Mitchell K 1147
9 Will Shelton 822
10 Harley 792
11 Sam Hensley 770
12 JWheel101 732
13 GtownRockyTop 150
14 Evan 123
15 hounddog3 100

Knottfair wins Week 16 of the 2020 GRT Pick ‘Em; birdjam remains season leader

Congratulations to Knottfair, who finished first in Week 16 of the 2020 GRT Pick ‘Em with a record of 10-6 and 106 confidence points, plus the tiebreaker over cnyvol, who had an identical record.

Here are the full results for this week:

Rank Player W-L Points Tiebreaker
1 Knottfair 10-6 106 31-17**
1 cnyvol 12-4 106 42-20
3 DinnerJacket 11-5 105 32-16**
3 Krusher 11-5 105 0-0
5 tmfountain14 11-5 103 45-20
6 C_hawkfan 11-5 102 28-21
7 Jayyyy 9-7 101 38-21**
7 ddayvolsfan 11-5 101 42-21
9 Bulldog 85 10-6 97 0-0
10 keeps corn in a jar 10-6 95 42-10
11 spartans100 10-6 94 28-21
12 LuckyGuess 10-6 93 31-16**
12 GeorgeMonkey 9-7 93 35-17
12 birdjam 9-7 93 27-13
15 patmd 9-7 92 48-17
16 Anaconda 9-7 91 32-20**
16 Hjohn 9-7 91 28-14
16 ltvol99 8-8 91 35-24
16 rollervol 8-8 91 35-0
16 Hunters Horrible Picks 9-7 91 13-17
21 Jahiegel 9-7 90 31-19**
21 joeb_1 9-7 90 38-27
23 crafdog 10-6 88 31-17**
23 jfarrar90 8-8 88 31-20
25 PAVolFan 9-7 87 28-17**
25 Joel @ GRT 9-7 87 34-17
27 boro wvvol 9-7 86 28-17
28 TennRebel 9-7 85 31-17**
28 MariettaVol1 10-6 85 36-16
28 Raven17 8-8 85 38-17
31 BlountVols 6-10 81 35-14
32 tcarroll90 8-8 80 34-21
33 ChuckieTVol 7-9 79 0-0
34 ga26engr 8-8 77 42-10
35 Neil 6-10 75 24-28
36 Tennmark 7-9 74 34-17
37 PensacolaVolFan 7-9 64 20-10
38 Timbuktu126 6-10 58 14-7
39 memphispete 0-16 57 -
39 Jackson Irwin 0-16 57 -
39 ctull 0-16 57 -
39 TennVol95 in 3D! 0-16 57 -
39 shensle6 0-16 57 -
39 volfan28 0-16 57 -
39 Fowler877 0-16 57 -
39 OriginalVol1814 0-16 57 -
39 Will Shelton 0-16 57 -
39 HOTTUB 0-16 57 -
39 GasMan 0-16 57 -
39 vols95 0-16 57 -
39 Wilk21 0-16 57 -
39 HUTCH 0-16 57 -
39 ed75 0-16 57 -
39 Picks of Someone 0-16 57 -
39 rsbrooks25 0-16 57 -
39 Rossboro 0-16 57 -

Season Standings

And birdjam, of course, remains in the season lead. He now has a record of 176-71 and 1718 points. Here are the complete season standings:

Rank Player W-L W-L % Points
1 birdjam 176-71 71.26 1718
2 PAVolFan 176-71 71.26 1705
3 tmfountain14 170-77 68.83 1703
4 LuckyGuess 172-75 69.64 1701
4 jfarrar90 172-75 69.64 1701
6 GeorgeMonkey 172-75 69.64 1695
7 Anaconda 168-79 68.02 1691
8 keeps corn in a jar 169-78 68.42 1681
9 TennRebel 170-77 68.83 1674
10 Jahiegel 168-79 68.02 1672
11 cnyvol 165-82 66.80 1666
12 spartans100 172-75 69.64 1664
13 Knottfair 168-79 68.02 1658
13 Bulldog 85 163-84 65.99 1658
15 joeb_1 159-88 64.37 1654
16 ChuckieTVol 162-85 65.59 1651
17 Tennmark 160-87 64.78 1650
18 MariettaVol1 157-90 63.56 1647
19 boro wvvol 162-85 65.59 1646
20 BlountVols 167-80 67.61 1644
20 Krusher 169-78 68.42 1644
22 DinnerJacket 165-82 66.80 1640
23 Hjohn 157-90 63.56 1635
24 Joel @ GRT 167-80 67.61 1631
25 Raven17 163-84 65.99 1629
26 crafdog 170-77 68.83 1606
27 patmd 171-76 69.23 1596
28 ltvol99 165-82 66.80 1574
29 ga26engr 165-82 66.80 1569
30 Hunters Horrible Picks 155-92 62.75 1565
31 tcarroll90 151-96 61.13 1551
32 Jayyyy 128-119 51.82 1543
33 C_hawkfan 159-88 64.37 1535
34 PensacolaVolFan 168-79 68.02 1519
35 ddayvolsfan 169-78 68.42 1502
36 rollervol 159-88 64.37 1495
37 Timbuktu126 152-95 61.54 1469
38 Neil 101-146 40.89 1376
39 Will Shelton 85-162 34.41 1356
40 vols95 72-175 29.15 1229
41 volfan28 78-169 31.58 1215
42 Picks of Someone 46-201 18.62 1126
43 HUTCH 18-229 7.29 1050
44 Fowler877 30-217 12.15 1034
45 memphispete 20-227 8.10 998
46 Wilk21 25-222 10.12 995
47 TennVol95 in 3D! 33-214 13.36 988
48 HOTTUB 3-244 1.21 935
48 ctull 3-244 1.21 935
48 ed75 3-244 1.21 935
51 Jackson Irwin 1-246 0.40 930
52 OriginalVol1814 0-247 0.00 926
52 GasMan 0-247 0.00 926
52 rsbrooks25 0-247 0.00 926
52 shensle6 0-247 0.00 926
56 Rossboro 0-247 0.00 686

Gameday Gameplan for Tennessee fans: Texas A&M

It’s Gameday on Rocky Top, and the 3-6 Tennessee Volunteers look to play the role of spoiler and pull off an upset against a No. 5-ranked Texas A&M squad motivated by a somewhat remote possibility of sneaking into the College Football Playoff. It’s also Conference Championship Weekend, with a couple of excellent games in the other time slots as well.

Here’s the Gameday Gameplan for Tennessee fans. Where and when to find the Vols game on TV, what other games to watch as well, and what to listen to and read as you wait for kickoff.

When is the Vols game, and how can I watch it?

Here are the particulars for today’s Tennessee game:

The best games for Vols fans to watch today

The suggested viewing plan for Vols fans today starts with the Tennessee game at noon on ESPN then continues with the best game of the afternoon slot (the ACC Championship game, which features two current Playoff teams in Clemson and Notre Dame) and the SEC Championship in the evening. If you’d rather for some reason, the Big 10 and Big 12 conference championships are also on at the same time as the Vols’ game.

Here’s our curated list of games to watch today:

Away Home Time TV TV TV
NOON
#5 Texas A&M Tennessee 12:00 PM ESPN LIVE GO VOLS!
AFTERNOON
#3 Clemson #2 Notre Dame 4:00 PM ABC Live ACC Championship
EVENING
#1 Alabama #7 Florida 8:00 PM CBS Live SEC Championship

And here’s a searchable version of today’s entire college football TV schedule:

DateAwayHomeTimeTV
12/19/20 #14 Northwestern #4 Ohio State 12:00 PM FOX
12/19/20 #5 Texas A&M Tennessee 12:00 PM ESPN
12/19/20 #10 Oklahoma #6 Iowa State 12:00 PM ABC
12/19/20 Washington State Utah 1:30 PM FS1
12/19/20 Air Force Army 3:00 PM CBSSN
12/19/20 Ole Miss LSU 3:30 PM SECN
12/19/20 Missouri Mississippi State 3:30 PM SECN Alt
12/19/20 #3 Clemson #2 Notre Dame 4:00 PM ABC
12/19/20 Minnesota Wisconsin 4:00 PM BTN
12/19/20 Boise State #24 San José State 4:15 PM FOX
12/19/20 Illinois Penn State 5:30 PM FS1
12/19/20 Stanford UCLA 7:00 PM ESPN
12/19/20 #1 Alabama #7 Florida 8:00 PM CBS
12/19/20 #23 Tulsa #9 Cincinnati 8:00 PM ABC
12/19/20 Arizona State Oregon State 10:30 PM ESPN
12/19/20 Vanderbilt #8 Georgia Canceled
12/19/20 #19 Louisiana #12 Coastal Carolina Canceled
12/19/20 Michigan #16 Iowa Canceled
12/19/20 Florida State Wake Forest Canceled
12/19/20 SMU UTSA Canceled
12/19/20 Michigan State Maryland Canceled
12/19/20 Georgia Tech #18 Miami Canceled
12/19/20 Arizona California Canceled

GRT games and contests

While you’re waiting for the games to begin, make sure that you submit your answers to the GRT Guessing Game questions and update your picks for the GRT Pick ‘Em.

GRT game-week audio

Here’s last week’s podcast:

And here is Will’s regular spot on WNML’s Sports 180 with Josh Ward and Heather Harrington.

Pre-game prep

To catch up on your pre-game reading, have a look at our game preview posts from earlier this week:

Go Vols!

The Gameday on Rocky Top Guessing Game: 2020 Week 16

It’s Friday before Gameday, and that means it’s time for the Gameday on Rocky Top Guessing Game. If you’ve played before, you know the deal, and you can skip to the questions below. If not, catch up here.

Let’sa go!

  1. Submit your answers to our questions below.
  2. Click the “Submit” button.
  3. Copy and paste your answers in the comments below.

Good luck!

This could be Tennessee’s best defense ever

So, it’s three games. Two against what we believed to be bubble teams, though Colorado has leapt to 33rd in KenPom on the strength of two absolute blowouts since then. An absolute blowout is now the expectation tonight when the Vols host Tennessee Tech, so we may not learn a whole lot more just yet. League play is 12 days away, and the opener at #16 Missouri may indeed feature the two best teams in the SEC. More answers are coming.

But let’s take a moment to begin to appreciate what may already be true: this might be the best Tennessee defense since…ever.

We’ll use KenPom data, as usual, and call it the modern era. In just three games, the Vols have already jumped up a tier in that history, now just decimal points (22.04 points better than the average team in 100 possessions) behind 2008 (22.17) and 2018 (22.27). Cuonzo’s 2014 team is next at 23.69, with the 2019 Vols still a bit away on the mountaintop (26.24), meaning they’d currently be a little more than a possession favorite on this team. Still, through three games, this Tennessee team statistically belongs in the conversation of, “Who’s the second-best Tennessee team ever?” That’s high praise.

But defensively, these Vols are the conversation.

Tennessee is third nationally in KenPom’s defensive efficiency ratings, trailing Texas Tech and Clemson. That number – 86.2 points allowed against the average team in 100 possessions – is the best in Knoxville, ever.

These Vols are seventh nationally in effective field goal percentage defense, and sixth nationally in creating turnovers. Keon Johnson and Josiah James are Top 50 players in steal percentage. And they’ve done all of this, so far, without fouling much: 29th nationally in free throw rate allowed. In three games, UT opponents have shot only 34 free throws, and are hitting just 25.4% from the arc, 33.6% from the floor.

So yeah, very good, and very good nationally. But this early, I think the most understandable context is what other great Tennessee defensive teams have done. So here’s the list of Vol defensive efficiency via KenPom, which goes back to 1997:

1. 2021 – 86.2 points allowed vs the average team in 100 possessions

Stay tuned.

2. 1999 – 88.0

Jerry Green’s second team thrived on shot-blocking and was so tough inside with C.J. Black, Isiah Victor, and Charles Hathaway. Freshman Vincent Yarbrough also created his fair share of havoc, while Brandon Wharton and Tony Harris were strong on the perimeter. This group stumbled out of the gate after a #9 preseason ranking and had some bad losses against good SEC teams on the road, but closed with six straight wins including a 91-56 blowout of #23 Florida and the SEC East clincher in the regular season finale against #13 Kentucky, one of my favorite Tennessee games ever. They ended the regular season 20-7…then lost to Mississippi State in their first SEC Tournament game. As a four seed, they beat Delaware in round one…then got smoked by Missouri State in round two. But their ceiling was quite high, as you’ll see more in a moment.

3. 2010 – 90.4

The Elite Eight squad was solid all around defensively, especially when operating at full strength. But they excelled at taking away the three ball, with J.P. Prince, Scotty Hopson, and Cameron Tatum all long enough to do so. Basketball was different even just 10 years ago, and while this team could find itself in foul trouble, their ability to make you beat them inside the arc and clean it up with Wayne Chism and Brian Williams from there almost carried them to the Final Four. In that NCAA Tournament run they held Kawhi Leonard to 12 points and San Diego State to 59, ran past 14-seed Ohio (68 points), survived a villainous 31 from Evan Turner in the Sweet 16 but kept Ohio State to 73, and lost 70-69 to Michigan State (Draymond Green with a dozen off the bench). In terms of defense, this group probably got the most out of its entire lineup than any of these teams…with the possible exception of, you know, this year.

4. 2000 – 90.9

Jerry Green, Year Three: the Vols maintained an elite shot-blocking presence and added freshman Ron Slay to their arsenal, with an incredibly deep squad capable of disrupting just about any lineup you threw their way. In the annals of Tennessee basketball heartbreak, few top this group: ranked in the Top 5 in mid-February, 24-5 at the end of the regular season and SEC Champions. They too stumbled in their first SEC Tournament game, but earned a four seed and beat the defending champs from UConn in round two. The top three seeds in the region all lost in round two, meaning the Vols were the highest ranked seed left going to the Sweet 16, where they led 8-seed North Carolina late…before faltering down the stretch. These Vols were 17th in offensive efficiency, 27th in defensive efficiency.

5. 2018 – 92.4

The most recent torchbearers, Rick Barnes’ first Vol tournament squad finished sixth nationally in defensive efficiency in 2018. While the 2019 squad gave up too many threes, which ultimately cost them in the end, the 2018 squad was elite on the arc in surrendering just 31.8% from three. James Daniel’s presence is the only personnel difference there, otherwise they were the same talented bunch that spent a month at number one the following season. Without Kyle Alexander, we saw their efficiency drop in costly fashion against Loyola Chicago.

Some of the other candidates we’d think of are just behind on this list: Kevin O’Neill’s last team is seventh, the 2008 squad is eighth, Cuonzo’s last team is ninth. They were all excellent in particular areas: O’Neill’s team inside the arc, the ’08 Vols at forcing turnovers, Cuonzo’s team at eliminating offensive rebounds.

Again, it’s early. But this Tennessee team is in the Top 10 nationally in two of the four factors, and in the Top 30 in another. They’re in the Top 30 in defending from two and from three.

It’s early. But the bar defensively isn’t just high…right now, they are the bar.

On blue-chip ratio, the gap, and bootstrapping into chickens or eggs

We’ve talked a lot about blue-chip recruiting ratio around here. The idea is that if a team wants to have legitimate national championship hopes, its recruiting class has to consist of at least 50% 5- and 4-star recruits.

That’s true, but it’s also true that football is a game of relativity, and as much as it matters that you hit certain standards, it matters more how you compare to your competition. As Will recently pointed out, a blue-chip ratio of 50% is probably not a high enough target for the Vols due to their schedule regularly featuring teams with even higher blue-chip ratios. When Alabama and Georgia are regularly hovering around 80%, the milestone of hitting 50% doesn’t matter nearly as much as it otherwise would.

The whole concept of “gap” in college football has been on my mind a lot lately. Everybody loves lists, and we have a tendency to look at them and draw conclusions based solely on rankings while completely ignoring the ratings that lead to those rankings. In doing so, we miss the gap. Being in second place doesn’t mean you’re in contention for first if you’re miles behind.

National Signing Day Part I on Wednesday got me thinking about recruiting gaps, and that led me to wonder just how much food was on the table and how much was being hoarded by the heavies in this league.

Using 247Sports’ data (including both signees and commits and current as of the morning of 12.17.20), there are 111 blue-chip recruits and 167 others. Over 81% of the blue-chips went to only six teams, less than half of the league.

That’s a huge disparity between the top six teams and the rest of the conference, but the disparity is also quite pronounced among those six. For instance, the sixth team on the list had only half as many blue-chips as the first. Alabama, whose kingdom extends from the castle campus to the recruiting trails, has a full 18% of all of the SEC blue-chip recruits.

Here’s a visual:

And here is the same information in another form:

One of Tennessee’s main challenges, of course, is not only that it is the sixth team on the list. And it’s not only that plus the fact that most of those other five teams have at least 50% more blue-chips than do the Vols. It’s both of those things, plus the fact that they have to play three (and sometimes four) of those teams every season. They could do well and never know it because so many of their regular opponents are doing even better.

All of that leads to a question about on-field strategy. If the coaching staff is committed to coaching techniques and game plans that rest on an assumption that you have more talent than your opponent, they’re essentially conceding at least three losses every year, at least until they can catch some of those other teams on the recruiting trail. The rub is that it’s hard to catch those other teams when they are also winning more often and turning coaches over less often than you are. And if you not only lose to more-talented teams but to less-talented ones as well, you have a real problem. You need wins to improve your blue-chip ratio, and you need a better blue-chip ratio to get more wins.

There’s both a chicken and egg shortage on Rocky Top. Tennessee doesn’t need both an elite blue-chip ratio and all the wins our hearts desire right now, but it does need to figure out how to bootstrap itself into one or the other quickly. Being sixth on a short list of luminaries is not an insignificant accomplishment, but in this case, it hides just how long the journey is to the desired destination.

What’s the solution? That, of course, is the million dollar question and will have to wait for another day and another post.