It feels like I’ve written a lot about continuity on this site over the past couple of years. I’ve looked at in-season starter continuity in the SEC, in-season offensive line continuity for the Vols, and long-term coordinator continuity for the Vols. Funny thing is, putting it under the microscope often reveals that continuity doesn’t impact a team’s performance as much as you think it should.
For instance, the two conclusions from the post about in-season starter continuity in the SEC were (1) it probably matters at the quarterback position, but (2) it didn’t seem to be nearly as important at other positions. Other factors such overall talent, player development, and coaching mattered more. And when we dove into in-season offensive line continuity for the Vols, we found (1) that it improved in 2018 over an absolute disaster in 2017, but (2) it didn’t have much of an effect on the team’s ability to gain yards or score points. Either it didn’t matter or any gains in that area were undone by other factors.
And then last September, I looked at coordinator continuity for the Vols, which was a hallmark of the program under Phillip Fulmer from 1992-2008 but became a certifiable mess for the following decade. Until his final season as head coach, Fulmer had one defensive coordinator and two offensive coordinators over the course of 16 seasons. In the following 12 seasons, the Vols’ football program hired four new head coaches, five new offensive coordinators (one of them twice at two different times), and seven new defensive coordinators.
But that didn’t really answer the question of whether coordinator churn, generally speaking, was merely a result of poor performance on the field or whether it might actually contribute to poor performance. As a Tennessee fan longing for the success the program enjoyed during most of the Fulmer Era, it felt more like a cause than an effect, but over the past couple of days, I decided to look at the same data league-wide. After cursing every SEC team’s media guide for listing its assistant coaches alphabetically instead of by year or position, I finally wrangled everything into one place so I could draw a firm conclusion as to whether coaching churn was good or bad for a team.
And now I finally have a definitive answer: It depends.
The entire data set is below for you to look at yourself, but here’s the summary:
Offense Better | Offense Worse | Defense Better | Defense Worse | |
HC, OC, DC | 7 | 8 | 10 | 5 |
OC, DC | 3 | 4 | 5 | 2 |
OC only | 11 | 8 | ||
DC only | 13 | 9 |
Basically, by replacing offensive coordinators over the past seven to nine years, SEC teams have been about as likely to make things worse as they were to make things better, at least in the first year after the change. They fared a little better replacing defensive coordinators, but programs often went backward then, as well.
Okay, but what about the second year in a new coordinator’s tenure? They have to get better once they hit their stride and all the players get up to speed in the new system, right?
Not necessarily, at least as to the offense. Out of 24 instances over the last nine seasons where a new SEC offensive coordinator was around for a second year in the same position, the offenses got worse exactly the same number of times as they got better.
But that doesn’t mean there isn’t an answer to the question of whether that shiny new coach is going to make your favorite team better or worse. There is an answer. It’s just that the answer is that it depends. It depends on the guy you hired. It depends on the guy he’s replacing and how good the team has recently been at the thing you’ve hired the new guy to do. It depends on the roster and the relative health of the ecosystem into which all of this newness is introduced. It just depends.
Continuity, then, is like a garbage-in, garbage-out computer system. It only produces the results you want if the data’s good.
The good news for Vols fans is that the data looks good. All of the other factors seem to be improving, and the guys on staff have a track record of being on the positive side of the data set.
Jeremy Pruitt
Because our analysis is limited to SEC head coaches and coordinators, it doesn’t include anything worthwhile on second-year Vols’ defensive coordinator Derrick Ansley. It’s probably safe to assume, though, that Jeremy Pruitt has as much or more to do with Tennessee’s defense as does Ansley, and we do have numbers on Pruitt.
When Georgia hired Pruitt as defensive coordinator in 2014, the Bulldogs had just held opponents to 376 yards per game the prior year. Pruitt improved total defense his first season, holding opponents to 337 yards per game in 2014. He improved it again in 2015, this time holding opponents to 306 yards per game. After two seasons under Pruitt, Georgia’s defense was allowing 70 fewer yards per game than it had been before he arrived.
When Pruitt arrived at Alabama in 2016, he did the same thing even though Alabama didn’t have much room to improve. The Tide’s defense had held opponents to 276 yards per game in 2015, and in Pruitt’s first season, they held opponents to 262. He squeezed out another couple of yards in his second season, improving to 260 before taking the job at Tennessee.
Jim Chaney
Jim Chaney’s record at three different stops in the SEC during the same time frame is also one of improvement. Hired at Tennessee in 2009 by Lane Kiffin, the offense immediately improved an impressive 115 yards per game, from 269 to 384. As a holdover from Kiffin’s staff when Derek Dooley and company arrived in 2010, Chaney’s offense actually took a small step backward (20 yards per game) in his second season and then another of 31 yards in 2011, although the blame for that one probably lies at the feet of early injuries to Tyler Bray and Justin Hunter. In 2012, Chaney and his offense hit their stride and put up 476 yards per game, somehow managing to stay 5 yards ahead of Sal Sunseri’s defense. To put a bow on it, Chaney’s offense at Tennessee improved 115 yards in his first season, then went down 20 and down another 31 before going back up 143.
Hired at Arkansas in 2013, Chaney’s offense had 357 yards in his first season. His offense improved to 406 yards per game in his second season before leaving for Pittsburgh, where he turned Nathan Peterman into an NFL quarterback.
When Georgia hired Chaney in 2016, he again immediately improved the offense, this time from 377 yards per game to 385 in his first season and then again to 435 in his second season. By his third season in 2018, the offense was cranking out 465 yards per game. And then he returned to Rocky Top.
For more on Jim Chaney, check out this post, a re-publication of an article Will wrote for the magazine last year:
Conclusion
Teams don’t always get better when they hire new coaches. Generally speaking, they tend to get worse as often as they get better. Whether they get better or worse depends on a variety of factors, and the guy being hired is chief among them. History shows that both Pruitt and Chaney are both guys that make things better when you hire them. They tend to improve their teams immediately and then continue to do so in their second and third years and beyond.
In case you’re interested, here’s the entire list of head coaches and coordinators for every SEC team since 2011, along with the teams’ respective total offense and total defense numbers where available from the NCAA.
Team | Year | HC | OC | DC | CHURN | TO | TD | O-Change | D-Change |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Tennessee | 2008 | Phillip Fulmer | Dave Clawson | John Chavis | OC | 269 | 264 | ||
Tennessee | 2009 | Lane Kiffin | Jim Chaney | Monte Kiffin | HC, OC, DC | 384 | 319 | 115 | -55 |
Tennessee | 2010 | Derek Dooley | Jim Chaney | Justin Wilcox | HC, DC | 364 | 382 | -20 | -63 |
Tennessee | 2011 | Derek Dooley | Jim Chaney | Justin Wilcox | 333 | 341 | -31 | 42 | |
Tennessee | 2012 | Derek Dooley | Jim Chaney | Sal Sunseri | DC | 476 | 471 | 143 | -131 |
Tennessee | 2013 | Butch Jones | Mike Bajakian | John Jancek | HC, OC, DC | 353 | 418 | -123 | 53 |
Tennessee | 2014 | Butch Jones | Mike Bajakian | John Jancek | 371 | 365 | 17 | 54 | |
Tennessee | 2015 | Butch Jones | Mike DeBord | John Jancek | OC | 422 | 362 | 52 | 3 |
Tennessee | 2016 | Butch Jones | Mike DeBord | Bob Shoop | DC | 444 | 449 | 21 | -87 |
Tennessee | 2017 | Butch Jones | Larry Scott | Bob Shoop | OC | 291 | 413 | -153 | 36 |
Tennessee | 2018 | Jeremy Pruitt | Tyson Helton | Kevin Sherrer | HC, OC, DC | 326 | 377 | 34 | 36 |
Tennessee | 2019 | Jeremy Pruitt | Jim Chaney | Derrick Ansley | OC, DC | 360 | 340 | 34 | 38 |
Florida | 2010 | Urban Meyer | Steve Addazio | Teryl Austin | |||||
Florida | 2011 | Will Muschamp | Charlie Weis | Dan Quinn | HC, OC, DC | ||||
Florida | 2012 | Will Muschamp | Brent Pease | Dan Quinn | OC | 334 | 288 | ||
Florida | 2013 | Will Muschamp | Brent Pease | D.J. Durkin | DC | 317 | 314 | -18 | -27 |
Florida | 2014 | Will Muschamp | Kurt Roper | D.J. Durkin | OC | 368 | 330 | 51 | -16 |
Florida | 2015 | Jim McElwain | Doug Nussmeier | Geoff Collins | HC, OC, DC | 334 | 310 | -34 | 20 |
Florida | 2016 | Jim McElwain | Doug Nussmeier | Geoff Collins | 344 | 293 | 10 | 17 | |
Florida | 2017 | Jim McElwain | Doug Nussmeier | Randy Shannon | DC | 336 | 349 | -8 | -56 |
Florida | 2018 | Dan Mullen | Billy Gonzalez/John Hevesy | Todd Grantham | HC, OC, DC | 427 | 343 | 91 | 6 |
Florida | 2019 | Dan Mullen | Billy Gonzalez/John Hevesy | Todd Grantham | 431 | 305 | 4 | 39 | |
Georgia | 2011 | Mark Richt | Mike Bobo | Todd Grantham | |||||
Georgia | 2012 | Mark Richt | Mike Bobo | Todd Grantham | 468 | 358 | |||
Georgia | 2013 | Mark Richt | Mike Bobo | Todd Grantham | 484 | 376 | 17 | -18 | |
Georgia | 2014 | Mark Richt | Mike Bobo | Jeremy Pruitt | DC | 458 | 337 | -26 | 38 |
Georgia | 2015 | Mark Richt | Brian Schottenheimer | Jeremy Pruitt | OC | 377 | 306 | -81 | 31 |
Georgia | 2016 | Kirby Smart | Jim Chaney | Mel Tucker | HC, OC, DC | 385 | 328 | 8 | -22 |
Georgia | 2017 | Kirby Smart | Jim Chaney | Mel Tucker | 435 | 295 | 51 | 33 | |
Georgia | 2018 | Kirby Smart | Jim Chaney | Dan Lanning | DC | 465 | 314 | 30 | -19 |
Georgia | 2019 | Kirby Smart | James Coley | Dan Lanning | OC | 408 | 276 | -57 | 39 |
Kentucky | 2011 | Joker Phillips | Randy Sanders | Rick Minter | |||||
Kentucky | 2012 | Joker Phillips | Randy Sanders | Rick Minter | 315 | 391 | |||
Kentucky | 2013 | Mark Stoops | Neal Brown | D.J. Eliot | HC, OC, DC | 341 | 427 | 26 | -36 |
Kentucky | 2014 | Mark Stoops | Neal Brown | D.J. Eliot | 384 | 407 | 43 | 20 | |
Kentucky | 2015 | Mark Stoops | Shannon Dawson | D.J. Eliot | OC | 372 | 394 | -12 | 13 |
Kentucky | 2016 | Mark Stoops | Eddie Gran | D.J. Eliot | OC | 420 | 434 | 48 | -40 |
Kentucky | 2017 | Mark Stoops | Eddie Gran | Matt House | DC | 350 | 427 | -70 | 7 |
Kentucky | 2018 | Mark Stoops | Eddie Gran | Matt House | 361 | 338 | 11 | 89 | |
Kentucky | 2019 | Mark Stoops | Eddie Gran | Brad White | DC | 393 | 325 | 32 | 13 |
LSU | 2011 | Les Miles | Greg Studrawa | John Chavis | |||||
LSU | 2012 | Les Miles | Greg Studrawa | John Chavis | 374 | 308 | |||
LSU | 2013 | Les Miles | Cam Cameron | John Chavis | OC | 453 | 341 | 79 | -33 |
LSU | 2014 | Les Miles | Cam Cameron | John Chavis | 388 | 317 | -66 | 24 | |
LSU | 2015 | Les Miles | Cam Cameron | Kevin Steele | DC | 437 | 347 | 50 | -30 |
LSU | 2016 | Les Miles/Ed Orgeron | Steve Ensminger | Dave Aranda | HC, OC, DC | 423 | 314 | -14 | 33 |
LSU | 2017 | Ed Orgeron | Matt Canada | Dave Aranda | OC | 411 | 316 | -12 | -2 |
LSU | 2018 | Ed Orgeron | Steve Ensminger | Dave Aranda | OC | 402 | 339 | -9 | -23 |
LSU | 2019 | Ed Orgeron | Steve Ensminger | Dave Aranda | 569 | 344 | 166 | -5 | |
Mississippi State | 2011 | Dan Mullen | Les Koenning | Chris Wilson | |||||
Mississippi State | 2012 | Dan Mullen | Les Koenning | Chris Wilson | 382 | 387 | |||
Mississippi State | 2013 | Dan Mullen | Les Koenning | Geoff Collins | DC | 434 | 349 | 53 | 38 |
Mississippi State | 2014 | Dan Mullen | Billy Gonzales/John Hevesy | Geoff Collins | OC | 514 | 424 | 79 | -75 |
Mississippi State | 2015 | Dan Mullen | Billy Gonzales/John Hevesy | Manny Diaz | DC | 461 | 391 | -53 | 33 |
Mississippi State | 2016 | Dan Mullen | Billy Gonzales/John Hevesy | Peter Sirmon | DC | 440 | 459 | -20 | -68 |
Mississippi State | 2017 | Dan Mullen | Billy Gonzales/John Hevesy | Todd Grantham | DC | 419 | 306 | -22 | 153 |
Mississippi State | 2018 | Joe Moorhead | Luke Getsy | Bob Shoop | HC, OC, DC | 397 | 263 | -21 | 43 |
Mississippi State | 2019 | Joe Moorhead | Andrew Breiner/Terry Richardson | Bob Shoop | OC | 400 | 399 | 3 | -136 |
Ole Miss | 2011 | Houston Nutt | David Lee | Tyrone Nix | |||||
Ole Miss | 2012 | Hugh Freeze | Matt Luke/Dan Werner | Dave Wommack/Wesley McGriff | |||||
Ole Miss | 2013 | Hugh Freeze | Matt Luke/Dan Werner | Dave Wommack/Jason Jones | 473 | 371 | |||
Ole Miss | 2014 | Hugh Freeze | Matt Luke/Dan Werner | Dave Wommack/Jason Jones | 419 | 329 | -54 | 42 | |
Ole Miss | 2015 | Hugh Freeze | Matt Luke/Dan Werner | Dave Wommack/Jason Jones | 518 | 386 | 99 | -57 | |
Ole Miss | 2016 | Hugh Freeze | Matt Luke/Dan Werner | Dave Wommack/Jason Jones | 464 | 461 | -53 | -76 | |
Ole Miss | 2017 | Matt Luke | Phil Longo | Wesley McGriff/Jason Jones | HC, OC, DC | 462 | 460 | -2 | 2 |
Ole Miss | 2018 | Matt Luke | Phil Longo | Wesley McGriff/Jason Jones | 511 | 483 | 48 | -24 | |
Ole Miss | 2019 | Matt Luke | Rich Rodriguez | Mike MacIntyre | OC, DC | 445 | 417 | -65 | 67 |
Missouri | 2011 | Gary Pinkel | David Yost | Dave Steckel | |||||
Missouri | 2012 | Gary Pinkel | David Yost | Dave Steckel | |||||
Missouri | 2013 | Gary Pinkel | Josh Henson | Dave Steckel | OC | 491 | 418 | ||
Missouri | 2014 | Gary Pinkel | Josh Henson | Dave Steckel | 367 | 346 | -124 | 71 | |
Missouri | 2015 | Gary Pinkel | Josh Henson | Barry Odom | DC | 281 | 302 | -86 | 44 |
Missouri | 2016 | Barry Odom | Josh Heupel | DeMontie Cross/Ryan Walters | HC, OC, DC | 501 | 480 | 220 | -178 |
Missouri | 2017 | Barry Odom | Josh Heupel | Barry Odom/Ryan Walters | DC | 502 | 414 | 2 | 66 |
Missouri | 2018 | Barry Odom | Derek Dooley | Ryan Walters | OC, DC | 482 | 389 | -20 | 26 |
Missouri | 2019 | Barry Odom | Derek Dooley | Ryan Walters | 374 | 312 | -108 | 77 | |
South Carolina | 2011 | Steve Spurrier | Steve Spurrier | Ellis Johnson | |||||
South Carolina | 2012 | Steve Spurrier | Steve Spurrier, Jr./Shawn Elliott | Lorenzo Ward | |||||
South Carolina | 2013 | Steve Spurrier | Steve Spurrier, Jr./Shawn Elliott | Lorenzo Ward | 452 | 350 | |||
South Carolina | 2014 | Steve Spurrier | Steve Spurrier, Jr./Shawn Elliott | Lorenzo Ward | 443 | 433 | -9 | -83 | |
South Carolina | 2015 | Steve Spurrier | G.A. Mangus | Jon Hoke/Lorenzo Ward | OC, DC | 362 | 430 | -81 | 3 |
South Carolina | 2016 | Will Muschamp | Bryan McClendon/Kurt Roper | Travaris Robinson | HC, OC, DC | 348 | 412 | -15 | 18 |
South Carolina | 2017 | Will Muschamp | Bryan McClendon | Travaris Robinson | 337 | 367 | -10 | 45 | |
South Carolina | 2018 | Will Muschamp | Bryan McClendon | Travaris Robinson | 426 | 424 | 89 | -57 | |
South Carolina | 2019 | Will Muschamp | Bryan McClendon | Travaris Robinson | 372 | 393 | -54 | 31 | |
Texas A&M | 2011 | Mike Sherman | Tim DeRuyter | ||||||
Texas A&M | 2012 | Kevin Sumlin | Kliff KIngsbury | Mark Snyder | |||||
Texas A&M | 2013 | Kevin Sumlin | Jake Spavital | Mark Snyder | 538 | 476 | |||
Texas A&M | 2014 | Kevin Sumlin | Jake Spavital | Mark Snyder | 455 | 451 | -83 | 25 | |
Texas A&M | 2015 | Kevin Sumlin | Jake Spavital | John Chavis | DC | 425 | 380 | -31 | 71 |
Texas A&M | 2016 | Kevin Sumlin | Noel Mazzone | John Chavis | OC | 467 | 442 | 42 | -62 |
Texas A&M | 2017 | Kevin Sumlin | Noel Mazzone | John Chavis | 407 | 409 | -60 | 33 | |
Texas A&M | 2018 | Jimbo Fisher | Darrell Dickey | Mike Elko | HC, OC, DC | 472 | 348 | 65 | 60 |
Texas A&M | 2019 | Jimbo Fisher | Darrell Dickey/Jay Graham | Mike Elko | 395 | 340 | -77 | 8 | |
Vanderbilt | 2011 | James Franklin | John Donovan | Bob Shoop | |||||
Vanderbilt | 2012 | James Franklin | John Donovan | Bob Shoop | |||||
Vanderbilt | 2013 | James Franklin | John Donovan | Bob Shoop | 367 | 355 | |||
Vanderbilt | 2014 | Derek Mason | Karl Dorrell | David Kotulski | HC, OC, DC | 288 | 402 | -78 | -47 |
Vanderbilt | 2015 | Derek Mason | Andy Ludwig | Derek Mason | OC, DC | 327 | 351 | 38 | 52 |
Vanderbilt | 2016 | Derek Mason | Andy Ludwig | Derek Mason | 356 | 408 | 29 | -58 | |
Vanderbilt | 2017 | Derek Mason | Andy Ludwig | Jason Tarver | DC | 351 | 393 | -5 | 15 |
Vanderbilt | 2018 | Derek Mason | Andy Ludwig | Jason Tarver | 411 | 439 | 60 | -46 | |
Vanderbilt | 2019 | Derek Mason | Gerry Gdowski | Jason Tarver | OC | 299 | 437 | -112 | 2 |
Alabama | 2011 | Nick Saban | Jim McElwain | Kirby Smart | |||||
Alabama | 2012 | Nick Saban | Doug Nussmeier | Kirby Smart | |||||
Alabama | 2013 | Nick Saban | Doug Nussmeier | Kirby Smart | 454 | 287 | |||
Alabama | 2014 | Nick Saban | Lane Kiffin | Kirby Smart | OC | 485 | 328 | 30 | -42 |
Alabama | 2015 | Nick Saban | Lane Kiffin | Kirby Smart | 427 | 276 | -57 | 52 | |
Alabama | 2016 | Nick Saban | Lane Kiffin | Jeremy Pruitt | DC | 455 | 262 | 28 | 15 |
Alabama | 2017 | Nick Saban | Brian Daboll | Jeremy Pruit | OC | 444 | 260 | -11 | 1 |
Alabama | 2018 | Nick Saban | Mike Locksley | Tosh Lupoi | OC, DC | 522 | 320 | 78 | -59 |
Alabama | 2019 | Nick Saban | Steve Sarkisian | Pete Golding | OC, DC | 511 | 325 | -11 | -5 |
Arkansas | 2011 | Bobby Petrino | Garrick McGee | Willy Robinson | |||||
Arkansas | 2012 | John L. Smith | Paul Petrino | Paul Haynes | |||||
Arkansas | 2013 | Bret Bielema | Jim Chaney | Chris Ash | HC, OC, DC | 357 | 413 | ||
Arkansas | 2014 | Bret Bielema | Jim Chaney | Robb Smith | DC | 406 | 323 | 49 | 90 |
Arkansas | 2015 | Bret Bielema | Dan Enos | Robb Smith | OC | 466 | 392 | 60 | -68 |
Arkansas | 2016 | Bret Bielema | Dan Enos | Robb Smith | 428 | 427 | -37 | -35 | |
Arkansas | 2017 | Bret Bielema | Dan Enos | Paul Rhoads | DC | 373 | 438 | -55 | -12 |
Arkansas | 2018 | Chad Morris | Joe Craddock | John Chavis | HC, OC, DC | 336 | 413 | -38 | 25 |
Arkansas | 2019 | Chad Morris | Joe Craddock | John Chavis | 340 | 451 | 4 | -38 | |
Auburn | 2011 | Gene Chizik | Gus Malzahn | Ted Roof | |||||
Auburn | 2012 | Gene Chizik | Scot Loeffler | Brian VanGorder | |||||
Auburn | 2013 | Gus Malzahn | Rhett Lashlee | Ellis Johnson | HC, OC, DC | 501 | 421 | ||
Auburn | 2014 | Gus Malzahn | Rhett Lashlee | Ellis Johnson | 485 | 399 | -16 | 22 | |
Auburn | 2015 | Gus Malzahn | Rhett Lashlee | Will Muschamp | DC | 370 | 405 | -115 | -6 |
Auburn | 2016 | Gus Malzahn | Rhett Lashlee | Kevin Steele | DC | 441 | 362 | 71 | 43 |
Auburn | 2017 | Gus Malzahn | Chip Lindsey | Kevin Steele | OC | 452 | 319 | 11 | 43 |
Auburn | 2018 | Gus Malzahn | Chip Lindsey | Kevin Steele | 390 | 355 | -62 | -36 | |
Auburn | 2019 | Gus Malzahn | Kenny Dillingham | Kevin Steele | OC | 407 | 337 | 17 | 18 |
I’m sure this is an unfair what-if, since I have no idea if Chaney was even available in 2008, but what if Fulmer hires Chaney instead of the Clawfense?
Also, wow the Clawfense was actually worse than Larry Scott’s offense in 2017!
Yeah, the Clawfense was clawful. And yes, I think things would have been much different if Fulmer had hired somebody whose scheme didn’t take longer to implement than Fulmer had.
Interesting… no one has come close to the Chavis days on defense… it seems the offense on a whole has been under pressure due to defensive breakdowns. Go Vols!
Tennessee has two of the five triple-digit positive jumps in yards per game/allowed on this list:
pretty interesting article I think the head coach matters more than the coordinators. Alabama changed theirs the last few years and still were contenders. I am a Kentucky fan and one of Barnhart’s mistakes was naming Joker Phillips coach in waiting. Stoops and Calipari are his best two hires not to mention others Lawson (softball) Skinner(volleyball) etc. Kentucky now has a comprehensive program that competes in nearly every sport in the SEC in the past you could not say that especially football, the AD did not care whether they won or lost. they put resources into it, facilities stayed the… Read more »